Tuesday, June 18, 2024

The Pemberton Mission to Bhutan (1837 – 1838)


 

The Pemberton Mission to Bhutan (1837 – 1838)

British realized that all communications from the British Government were withheld by the Bhutanese frontier officers. Now they wanted to send a special Mission to Bhutan to find out the true information about Bhutan.

The Mission has four main objectives to be achieved. They are given below:[1]

1.     - To establish diplomatic relation with the Bhutan Government

2.     -  To resolve the problems of tribute payment for the duars to further reduce the border conflict in the area.

3.     -  To persuade the Bhutan to make over the management of the Assam Duars in lieu of our payment

4.     -  To settle the terms of the commercial treaty of 1774 which was remained suspended so far.

The Mission was headed by Captain R. Boileau Pemberton. Other members of the Mission include Ensign M.T. Blake as a surveyor and Dr. W.M. Griffit, as an assistant surgeon and about 50 men of escort of the Assam Sebundy Corps.They decided to trek the route from eastern Bhutan unlike the past Missionaries. East India Company communicated to the Bhutan Government about the captain Pemberton’s Mission to Bhutan.

The Mission started from Calcutta by water to Gauhati in Assam. The Mission was delayed at Gauhati from 8th to 21st December. The reason for the delay was that they were waiting for the communication from the Deb Raja of Bhutan.

Although there was no welcoming note from the Dewangiri, the Mission started on 21st December 1837. The Mission reached Dewangiri on 23rd January 1838. They were delayed there nearly a month at Dewangiri as there was no information from Punakha to welcome them.

Moreover, when the Mission was at Dewangiri, a rebellion by the Daga Penlop Dorji Norbu against the 35th Desi Choki Gyaltshen was broke out.[2] But the Bhutanese source says that it was Zhongar Dzongpon Chagpa Sangye removed the Desi from the throne and enthroned his brother Daga Penlop Dorji Norbu.

In the meantime, they were asked to return back and told to go from the Buxa Duar route where the past missionaries followed. Finally, after receiving the permission from the Trongsa penlop, they started their journey from Dewangiri. The permission to proceed to Punakha was given with condition that they were not allowed to talk or interview any Bhutanese People.[3]

From Kheri Gonpa, present day Pemagatshel, there was a direct route to go to Punakha via

Zhongar. This was the main route people followed in those days while travelling to Dewangiri to Punakha. Near the Kheri Gonpa, at a place called Shalikhar, there was a small dzong which served as an office of Jadrung.

From Kheri Gonpa, Pemagatshel, the Mission was asked to go from Trashigang, Trashi Yangtse, Lhuntse, Jakar, Trongsa and then to Punakha. This was because the Dzongpon of Zhongar Chagpa Sangye was the brother of the Daga Penlop who revolted against the Desi. To support his brother’s forces, Zhongar Dzongpon was gathering the militia from villages under his jurisdiction.[4]

 

                                Route followed by Captain Pemberton and his team

                                Note: The route is not to the scale.

 

Zhongar Dzongpon was the subordinate of the Trongsa Penlop. But there was no mentioned of the Trongsa Penlop’s involvement in the revolt. Did Dzongpon independently carry out the rebellion against the Desi?

Captain R. Boileau Pemberton was accompanied by Ensign M.T. Blake as a surveyor and Dr. W.M. Griffit, as an assistant surgeon. Dr. Griffit also maintained a journal during the mission’s visit to Bhutan. He mentioned that Kheri Gonpa was a good place. At Kheri Gonpa he observed many rhododrondon trees but he was not happy at Trongsa and Punakha.  

After the arrival at Punakha, the members of the Mission were given audience by the new Desi Dorji Norbu. Former Zhonger Dzongpon Chagpa Sangye was the Deb Zimpon and acted as the interpreter between the Desi and members of Mission.[5] Bhutanese source says that after appointing his brother Dorji Norbu Desi, he took the post of Wangdu Phodrang Dzongpon.The following day, members of the mission also had a meeting with the young Dharma Raja. Griffith observed that the throne room of the Dharma Raja was not as decorated as the throne room of the Desi. Captain Boileau Pemberton was given the draft treaty to make Bhutanese Government sign the treaty but unfortunately he counld not make the Bhutanese Government sign the treaty. The reasons for the failure of the Mission are mentioned in the following pages.

 Failure of the Pemberton’s Mission to Bhutan

Captain Pemberton found the situations at Punakha not settled well, when he reached there. Captain Pemberton had to be cautious while dealings with the Bhutanese authorities.  He had to do in such way that he should not hurt the sentiments of the both reigning Desi Dorji Norbu and the ex-Desi Choki Gyaltshen. The other members of the Council expressed their helpless to talk to the Mission.[6] While the Desi and some council members agreed to the proposal of the Pemberton, Trongsa Penlop did not approve it.[7] Trongsa Penlop was powerful Governor who controls whole eastern region of Bhutan.The then Trongsa Penlop was the Ugyen Phuntsho who later became the father in-law of Gongsa Jigme Namgyal.[8] But Pemberton’s report mentions that the Trongsa Penlop was Chogyal Tenzin, the father of Zhabdrung Jigme Norbu.

 The Pemberton’s Mission failed to achieve anything. So the Mission went back through Buxa Duar route. The failure of the Pemberton’s Mission was attributed to the civil strife being fought in the country. In addition, the East India Company wanted Bhutanese to pay in Company’s rupees instead of Deba/Deb rupees (Bhutanese coins) which was circulating in Bhutan. [9]

Moreover, the company’s rupees were not procurable in Bhutan or not a legal tender.  A Bhutanese envoy accompanied captain Pemberton to Calcutta to carry on negotiations but the Bengal Government authority rejected as the company’s mission was failed due to the non-cooperation provided by the Bhutanese leaders. [10]

 


                                               

Bhutan’s Deba coin[11]       


                                                                   





  ½ Rupee - Narendra Narayan[12]

The Situation inside Bhutan

During this time of the year, Choki Gyaltshen (2nd time) was the Desi of Bhutan. The Zhongar Dzongpon Chagpa Sangye attacked the Punakha Dzong and removed the incumbent Desi Choki Gyaltshen from the throne. Then he enthroned his elder brother Dorji Norbu as the next Desi from Daga Penlop. This was the main reason behind why Bhutanese authority did not allow the Pemberton and his team to proceed from Kengkhar to Zhongar route to go to Punakha. Zhongar was his area and there was risk or danger to travel from this route. For their safety, they were made to travel from trouble free places. The trouble arose immediately after the departure of the Pemberton’s Mission. The supporters of the previous Desi Choki Gyaltshen enthroned Thimphu Dzongpon Tashi Dorji as their Desi. Desi Tashi Dorji ruled from Thimphu while Desi Dorji Norbu ruled from Punkha.

Zhadrung Jigme Norbu from Dratmetse of Mongar was enthroned as the Dharma Raja at Punakha. He was around nine year of age. He received learning and training from his tutor Yongzin Pema Zangpo. His father Tenzin Chogyal, the then Trongsa Ponlop could not leave his son at Punakha in the midst of trouble. Tenzin Chogyal wanted to take away his son because he could foresee risk and danger for the life of his son.  So they planned in such a way that nobody knows that the young Zhabdrung was being taken away from the Dzong area. First they made the Zhabdrung’s tutor Yongzin Pema Zangpo to go as if to do ritual. The Young Zhabdrung was put into a leather bag as if vegetables and being taken out from the Dzong premises.

While negotiating the peace between the two factions, as Trongsa Penlop Tenzin Chogyal sided with the Desi Tashi Dorji, he was assassinated by the Desi Dorji Norbu’s men. The Young Zhabdrung Rinpoche went to Thimphu and lived in the Tashichhodzong.

 Final Annexation of Duars of Assam by British

The outrages continued by Bhutanese. In 1839, Bhutanese carried off eleven British subjects. With an offer to farm the Deb Raja’s right in the duars, captain F. Jenkins sent a native messenger to Bhutan through his own initiative. But the messenger was detained by Bhutanese. The local Bhutanese authorities in the duars also stopped paying tributes altogether.

Therefore, the two duars of Kalling and Boori Guma were taken possession by the British.[13] But Mackenzie and Lahiri write three duars of Kalling, Boori Guma and Ghaukolla were taken by British. In 1841 British received a letter each from the Bhutan Deb Raja and Dharma Raja. Deb Raja in his letter expressed surprise at the poor quality of articles reported to have been sent by his officers as tribute. He could not understand "why these were not rejected and returned. However, he assured the British Government that he had given strict orders to his agents in the duars to be more careful in future in the selection of the articles of tribute. In this letter, the Deb Raja also promised to pay the arrears by installments.

The Dharma Raja also wrote in the same tone and requested the British Government to release the attached duars. The Deb Raja also sent two messengers at this time instructing them to pay the arrears accumulated and also to settle the pending boundary dispute. In his letter he apologized that owing to the confusion prevailing in the hills, His Highness failed to send the messenger earlier as requested by the British Government.

The agent of the Governor General of the North East Captain F. Jenkins suggested to the Governor General Lord Auckland that British may send another Mission to Bhutan to resolve the dispute peacefully. But the Governor General Lord Auckland did not accept the recommendation of the agent saying that there would be no use of sending Mission to Bhutan because the situation was still not settled. The Governor General gave warning that anarchy situation in Bhutan is affecting the British. If such situations continued indefinitely, British would compel to occupy the duars without reference to the Deb Raja.

As the situations did not improve, the Bengal Government ordered the agent to annex the whole Assam duars permanently. British gave the reason that the annexation of the Duars was to maintain peace and order. There was no action of any sort from Bhutan. British Government paid Rs. 10,000/- annually as the compensation for the loss of Revenue.

 The Reasons for the Annexation of Assam

Bhutan got Assam duars from the Ahom Kings and in return Bhutan gave tribute in kinds to the Ahom Kings. This system functioned well between Bhutan and Ahom Kings. The conflicts arose in Assam duars after the annexation of Assam by the Company only. The company blamed the Bhutanese for the situations in Assam Duars. The Bhutanese actions in the Assam Duars were taken as pretext by the company to take over the Assam Duars from Bhutanese. William Bentinck, the then Governor General sent Jenkins in 1832 to Assam to examine and report on the resources of the Assam after its annexation of Assam in 1826.[14] Jenkins reported that Assam was suitable for the plantation of tea, where commercial tea plantation could be carried out in Assam. Then Tea Committee was formed to carry out the tea cultivation in Assam and by 1859, about 4000 acres of land were under the cultivation of tea and outputs of 76000 pounds of tea were produced.[15] The Company found the land in the Duars was fertile to cultivate any crops and found a great potential to generate revenue for the Company.  

At the same time, in the west, there was conflict between Gorkha and Sikkim over a track of land. Sikkim approached the company for help. William Bentinck took opportunity and sent Captain Herbert the deputy Surveyor General for a further survey of the area. The report of Captain Herbert was favourable and William Bentinck imagined that the Company would get considerable political benefit from the acquisition of the hill territory. So, in 1830 William Bentinck sent Captain Lloyd to open negotiations with the Chogyal Tsurphu Namgyal of Sikkim for the transfer of Darjeeling to the Company.[16] It was very clear that the company under the Governorship of William Bentinck followed the forward policy to take over Assam from Bhutan and Darjeeling from Sikkim.

 A series of internal conflict in the country

There were two Desis in the country. Dorji Norbu ruled from Punakha while Tashi Dorji ruled from Thimphu. When Dorji Norbu passed away in 1847, Tashi Dorji became the next full fledge Desi of Bhutan. His reign lasted till 1850.

The next Desi was Wangchug Gyalpo.  After few months of Wangchug Gyalpo became Desi, there was conflict in Paro between the former Paro Ponlop Agay Haap and Paro Ponlop Yonten Rinchen or Tazi Dronma. Desi Wangchug Gyalpo was found impartial in dealings with the two Ponlops. Therefore, he was assassinated by the Thinphu Dzongpon Tshewang and Lamai zimpon Sonam Dendup.

Then the Wangdu Dzongpon Chagpa Sangye challenged the Thimphu Dzongpon. A battle was fought at Luntenphu. Thimphu Dzongpon was killed in the battle at Lungtenphu. Wangdu Dzongpon Chagpa Sangye attempted to ascend on the throne as the next Desi but his candidature was rejected by the central monk body. The supporters of the Zhabdrung Jigme Norbu were enthroned as the next Desi in 1850.  He served as Desi till 1852. When Desi Zhabdrung Jigme Norbu retired due to illness, Chagpa Sangye seized the throne and became next Desi himself. Then the supporters of Zhabdrung Jigme Norbu and the central monk body requested assistance from Trongsa Ponlop Tshokey Dorji. Trongsa Ponlop sent his forces led by Dronyer Jigme Namgyal. Trongsa Dronyer Jigme Namgyal killed the Desi’s champion fighter Mikthoem at Norbugang. After this event, Jigme Namgyal left to Trongsa leaving the Desi on the throne. But shortly afterwards Desi was killed by his staunch enemy the former Paro Ponlop Agay Haap by offering the contaminated small pox silk gho to Desi in 1852.

In 1854, the Forty Second Desi Jamgon Trulku Jamyang Tenzin (reign: 1854-1855) sent intimation that the compensation paid was insufficient and demanded the increase of the amount. The Bhutanese officials include the Dewangiri Dzongpon and the brother of the Zhabdrung Jigme Norbu. He was Sonam Dendup. He served as the Zimpon of the Zhabdrung. When British refused to comply, Bhutan carried out raids on Assam.

The British Government reported to the Zhabdrung and Desi on the outrages committed by the Bhutanese officials. Zhabdrung and Desi sent an order to the Trongsa Penlop Jigme Namgyal to pay double the estimated value of the property looted by the Dewangiri Dzongpon and his associates. Trongsa Penlop Jigme Namgyal also wrote a letter to the British Government Agent in Assam. Trongsa Penlop informed the Agent of the Bengal Government in Assam that since Dewangiri Dzongpon was responsible for the atrocities committed in the British territory, he was removed from his office. Further Trongsa Penlop also wrote that British Government in Assam also bears half of the fine imposed to Dewangiri Dzongpon.[17]

In 1856, Lord Dalhousie, the Governor General replied to the Trongsa Penlop that if the compensation for the plundered properties carried out by Dewangiri Dzongpon was not paid to British, the amount would be deducted from the annual compensation owed to the Bhutanese Government.[18]

Governor General further warned Bhutan that any further outrages would lead to the permanent annexation of the duars on the Bengal side also.[19] There was no effect on Bhutan. Year after year fresh violations and incidents took place. For example, Arun Singh the Zamindar of Guma Duar was forcibly carried off into Bhutan. The British Governor requested the return of Arun Singh and those culprits should be punished. Bhutan claimed that Arun Singh was a Bhutanese but left Bhutan and resided in Assam for sometimes only. So, Desi Jamgon Trulku Jamyang Tenzin replied that Arun Singh could not be sent back to British Government.

 The East India Company replaced by British India Government in 1858.

During this time of the year, the East India Company was facing revolt from the Indian native people. This was called the Mutiny of 1857 which was considered by the Indain people as the first war of independence. The company postponed their actions of sending mission to Bhutan and attacking Bhutan.

After the Mutiny of 1857, the administration of India was directly placed under the Queen’s rule. The East India Company was replaced by the British India Government.The title of Governor General was also replaced by Viceroy. The Lord Hasting was the first Viceroy of British India Government. The Bengal Government would be headed by Leiutenant Governor.

 Internal Strife in Bhutan 1857

After the Desi Jamgon Trulku Jamyang Tenzin passed away, Wangdi Phodrang Dzongpon Kuenga Palden became the next Desi of Bhutan. The Thimphu Dzongpon Uma Dewa revolted against the Desi. He asked help from Trongsa Ponlop Jigme Namgyal. The combined forces of Thimphu Dzongpon and Trongsa Penlop defeated the Desi Kunega Palden. Then Uma Dewa became the next Desi of Bhutan. But very soon, ex-Desi Kuenga Palden assassinated the Desi Uma Dewa and he declared himself as the next Desi of Bhutan.

 In the same year, a battle was fought at Samkhar in Bumthang between the Trongsa Penlop Jigme Namgyal and Jakar Dzongpon Tsondrue Gyaltshen. The real cause for the battle was that in 1853, when Jigme Namgyal became Trongsa Penlop there was an understanding that after three years Jigme Namgyal should vacate the post of Trongsa Penlop to Jakar Dzongpon Tsondrue Gyaltshen who was the son of former Trongsa Ponlop Tshokey Dorji.  After serving three years as Trongsa Penlop Jigme Namgyal continued to be a Trongsa Penlop and there was no sign of vacating the post of Trongsa penlop to Tsondrue Gyaltshen. Therefore, Tsondroe Gyaltshen took to an arm rebellion against the Jigme Namgyal. The Je Khenpo and monk body mediated between the two parties and peace was established in the country.

 The Annexation of Bengal Duars

After the completion of the annexation of the Assam duars, British Indian Governemnt turned to the Bengal Duars. In 1860, British annexed the Province of Fallacotta which belonged to Bhutan. In 1862, Governor General Lord Eglin sent a messenger called Mokundo Singh to the Bhutanese Court to inform the proposed Mission to Bhutan. The messenger should ask the Bhutanese authorities that by which route and when the Mission should enter into Bhutan. The Bhutanese Government should also arrange the necessary protocol to receive the British Mission to Bhutan.

The messenger was delayed by the frontier officers and he could return only in December 1862. He brought a letter from the Desi. In the letter, Desi Nadzi Passang (reign: 1861-1863) wrote that he would send two or three messengers who would settle the disputes according to his order. However, no messengers came to Assam from Bhutan. This was because of the internal strife going on between the Punakha Dzongpon Darlung Tobgye’s party and Desi’s party.

Meanwhile, news reached to the office of British India that Bhutanese were preparing to attack Ambari Falakata and an attack on Darjeeling was apprehended. Therefore, troops were sent to the Darjeeling and Jaipalguri frontiers. Troops included two companies of His Majesty’s 38th foot and a wing of the 10th native infantry of Dinapore and a wing of ireregular calvary of Oudh.[20] This arrangement was done because in the previous year only Darjeeling was annexed to British India from Sikkim Raja. Bhutan and Tibet objected and accused Sikkim for selling the tract of Darjeeling to the East India Company.[21] Tibetan were worried about the political development in Sikkim and Tibetan did not allow the Sikkim Raja to use the traditional rights of grazing on the Tibetan border and Bhutanese attempted to assassinate the Sikkim Raja on his way to Tibet for pilgrimage.[22] But Bhutanese source did not mention about the assassination of the Sikkim Raja while confirmed the making of the preparations to attack Sikkim.[23]

 The Reasons for the Annexation of the Bengal Duars

The East India Company got rights to cut timber from the forests in the Bengal Duars of Bhutan by the Anglo-Bhutanese treaty of 1774. For sometimes, peace was prevailed in the Bengal Duars with the exception of the conflict over Magahrat between Bhutan and Cooch Behar Raja.

After the settlement of the Magahrat issue in favour for Bhutan, a long period of peace was prevailed in the region. But the conflicts started later in the boder areas of the Bengal Duars. The conflicts included daicoty, kidnapping and outrages. British India blamed Bhutan for the conflicts and looked for ways and means to punish Bhutanese people. Actually border disputes were caused by both the Bhutanese people as well as by the subjects of the British India. Some subjects of British India stole cattle and sold to Bhutanese.[24]

The whole region of both Bengal and Assam Duars were found to be fertile for the cultivation of tea, indigo, cotton etc. As mentioned before, particularly Bengal Duars was the source of timber extraction for the British India. At the end of the Duar war 1865, on estimation of the value of the land in the Bengal and Assam Duars, British India found out that the land could generate annual revenue of about a lakh and a half of rupees or (£15000) per annum.[25]

 Internal Strife in Bhutan (1862 – 1863)[26]

Punakha Dzongpon Darlung Tobgye was expected to be appointed as Wangdue Phodrang Dzongpon, when Nadzi Passang, the former Wangdue Phodrang Dzongpon became Desi. The new Desi Nadzi Passang appointed his nephew Sigyel who was Wangdue Phodrang Zimpon as the new Wangdue Phodrang Dzongpon. Then the Punakha Dzongpon Darlung Tobgye revolted against the Desi. He was aided by Zhung Kalyon Kawang Mangkhrel and Zhung Dronyer Drang Tashi.

The Desi was supported by Wangdue Phodrang Dzongpon Sigyel, Thimphu Dzongpon Karma Drugyel and the Paro Penlop Nyima Dorji.

In the course of the war, Punakha Dzongpon Darlung Tobgye requested helps from Jakar Ponlop Tsundru Gyaltshen and Trongsa Ponlop Jigme Namgyal.

Both the Jakar and Trongsa penlop marched towards the Thimphu after crossing Dochula fully prepared for war.

Trongsa Penlop Jigme Namgyal killed the Shar Drungpa Chudrag Gyamtsho who was leading the army of Wangdue Phodrang Dzongpon. Then the Wangdue Phodrang Dzongpon Sigyel and Thimphu Dzongpon requested Trongsa Penlop Jigme Namgyal to pardon them and not to kill them where Trongsa Penlop Jigme Namgyal agreed on conditions that they should not leave the country.

Meanwhile, the Monk Body mediated and peace was established in the country. Nyima Dorji remained as Paro Penlop, while Darlung Tobgye became the Wangdue Phodrang Dzongpon, Dronyer Drang Tashi was appointed as Punakha Dzongpon and Zhung Tapon Khasar Tobgye who was a distance relative of Trongsa Penlop Jigme Namgyal was made Thimphu Dzongpon.

The Desi Nadzi Passang retired in 1863 and succeeded by Tshewang Sithub (reign: 1863-64). There was a brief trouble again in the country. Since Tshewang Sithub was from the lower Wang valley, the people of the upper Wang valley were not happy with enthronement of the Tshewang Sithub. The people of the upper Wang valley appointed Tshultrim Yonten (reign: 1864-1864) as the new Desi. However, the Tshultrim Yonten passed away. At the same time, Tshewang Sithub also retired from the throne. Therefore, Kargyu Wangchug (reign: 1864-1864) became the next Desi of Bhutan. Desi Kargyu Wangchug was briefly followed by Desi Tsondru Pekar (1864-1864). Tshewang Sithub (reign: 1864- 1870) became Desi second time. It was during his time that Bhutan received a letter mentioning the imminent coming of the Ashley Eden Mission.

Since there were no messengers being deployed either to Calcutta or Assam as per the promise made by the Desi, British decided to send Ashley Eden as envoy to Bhutan in September 1863.



[1] Singh (1988), Labh (1974)

[2] Pemberton (1838)

[3] Tshewang (1994)

[4] Pemberton (1838)

[5] Griffith (1838)

[6] Lahiri (1954)

 

[7] Griffith (1838)

[8] Tshewang (1994)

[9] Rhodes, Nicholas (   ) Deba rupee is lower than that of Narainee rupee.

[10] Lahiri (1954)

[11] https://www.pinterest.com/pin/

[12] https://en.numista.com/catalogue.cooch_behar_princely-1.html

[13] Tshewang (1994)

[14] Bhuyan (1949)

[15] Gait, 1906)

[16] Singh (1988)

[17] Tshewang (1994)

[18] Tshewang (1994) and Mackenzie (1884)

[19] Mackenzie (1884)

[20] Buckland, (1901), Dash (1947)

[21] Arora (2008)

[22] Singh (1988)

[23] Tshewang (1994)

[24] Singh (1988)

[25] Buckland (1901)

[26] Tshewang (1994)

Wednesday, April 10, 2024

The Delivery of Guns to British India at Drangme Zam below the Shalikhar Dzong.

 

The Delivery of Guns to British India at Drangme Zam below the Shalikhar Dzong.

In accordance with the agreement signed between British and Bhutan, the guns were supposed to return by 10 January 1866. But Trongsa Penlop Jigme Namgyal refused to accept the terms of peace signed by Desi. Jigme Namgyal wanted to negotiate separately with British which were declined by the British India Government.

Meanwhile, on January 19th, 1866, Major General Frazer Tytler reported to Government that Trongsa Penlop refused to give the guns up and openly defied the British. As a result, orders were issued for an advance to be made against Trongsa Penlop. General Tytler was not willing to act provided he was given a large force. General Tytler resigned when Government appointed Colonel Richardson to command the expedition. But Lady MacGregor writes that Government decided to send the column to Trongsa under the command of Colonel Richardson because the Government was hurried to send the column to Trongsa as General Tytler’s plan of operations was delay considerably.

Colonel Richardson proceeded to Trongsa from Dewangiri on 4th February, 1866. The Colonel Richardson’s forces included: 3 Companies of the 26th Native Infantry, and 1Company of Sappers and Miners.

On 5th, Colonel Richardson received a letter from the Lama of Yongla Gonpa saying some of the Dzongpons were preparing to fight and that they may destroy the bridge over the river Drangme, which was then known as “Drangme Zam” that lies below the Shalikar Dzong on the way to Zhongar. Colonel Richardson made a quick dash to seize the bridge on 6th February. On arrival near the Shalikhar Dzong, they were attacked by Bhutanese, where their two men wounded. They pushed down to Drangme Zam without retaliation the Bhutanese ambush because their main intention was to take control of the Drangme Zam. To their surprise, the bridge was found intact on their arrival. However, on 23rd February, 1866, the guns were handed over to Colonel Richardson. After receiving the guns, Colonel Richardson immediately returned to Dewangiri.

Mr. Grey was appointed as a political officer in the right column during the war time. So he continued to serve in the same capacity when British force made an advance to Trongsa from Dewangiri. British force reached at Drangme Zam on 7th February. They halted there from 8th to 22nd February. They had provisions for three days only. They went to Salikhar to collect some provisions. On 13th February, Mr. Grey visited Yongla lam. The Lam welcomed him and treated him well. Through Lama, Mr. Grey communicated to Desi of Bhutan. On 16th, Desi wrote to Grey informing him that he had sent men to bring guns. Moreover, on 8th February, Lama had sent message to Trongsa Ponlop Jigme Namgyal that Britsh force had arrived at Drangme Zam and urging to surrender the guns.

After waiting and negotiating some days, finally, the guns were delivered to British forces at Drangme Zam on 22nd February. Along with two guns, seventy two British soldiers who were captured during war time by Bhutanese were released).  But there was nothing mentioned about the Bhutanese soldiers who were in the hand of British.

 On 26th February, Mr. Grey returned to Dewangiri but the forces came back on 3rd March 1866.  This terminated the conflict between Bhutan and British India.

This British report does not tally with the beliefs of the local people which state that the Shalikhar Dzong was destroyed by the British forces on their way to Trongsa to get the guns.        

The British Political officer and commander in-chief were given strict orders not to harm the common Bhutanese people. They were instructed to bring back the guns. They were told to burn down the Dzong where Trongsa Ponlop Jigme Namgyal live, in case he did not give up the guns and if they were to go to Trongsa. There is a written letter from the Viceroy to Mr. Grey which is worth sharing:

 

“CALCUTTA 3rd February 1866.

“DEAR MR. GREY,

In the approaching expedition against Tongso, you must be careful to communicate

fully and freely with Colonel Richardson and on all military points be guided by his judgment.

“It is very desirable that we should reach Tongso, and punish the chief if he does not send the guns. I am in great hopes that when he hears that the force has advanced, or at any rate has proceeded some marches on the way towards him, he will submit and restore the guns. Should he do so, the objects of the expedition will be accomplished and the force should fall back. “But however anxious I am to accomplish these objects, you must understand that I am still more desirous of avoiding disaster. If, therefore, supplies should fail, or carriage fall short, or the difficulties of the way prove, in the judgment of Colonel Richardson, insurmountable, or even greater than it may appear expedient to encounter, then it will rest with that officer to give up the expedition. “I do not apprehend much from the efforts of the Bhutias, but the route is long and difficult, and supplies for the troops are of primary importance. Unless these are secured, it will not be safe to advance.

“It will be a great point to establish such depots as may be considered necessary, in strong positions where water is available, and to throw up a sufficient defence against sudden attack.

"You are at liberty to spend any money which may be required for any purpose connected with the expedition, and when good information is furnished or even risk run in attempting to procure it, pay liberally. Take sufficient money with you. Keep a good lookout, see that proper discipline is enforced, and protect the peaceable inhabitants of the country.

"You may quite reckon on my support and countenance. “Should the force reach Tongso and fail to recover the guns, blow up the chief fort. I anticipate that he will not stand an attack, but will retreat into the interior. In that case the object will be to damage his power and prestige as much as possible. Don't remain at Tongso longer than is prudent. "If the Bhutan Government or any of their people show a disposition to help in coercing the Tongso, encourage them to do so, but don't pay them any money, and take suit able precautions against treachery without appearing to distrust them more than is necessary.” If the Tongso Penlo comes in, or gives up the guns,

treat him and his people courteously, but do not pay them any money. I have no objection to his receiving eventually any portion of the sum we shall pay annually to the Bhutan Government-either direct or through them, but this point must be settled by the Government of India in communication with the Deb and Dharm Rajas. And in no case am I willing to pay the Tongso Penlo money either for, or immediately after the surrender of the guns. On any doubtful

point, write and telegraph for orders. Don't pay the Tongso Penlo any money without such orders. -

Yours sincerely,                                                                                   

JOHN LAWRENCE."


Reference

1) Grey, Colonel L.J.H. 1912. Tales of our Grandfather, India since 1856, Printed by BAI.LANTYNE, HANSON &. CO., At the Ballantyne Press, Edinburgh.

2) MacGregor, Lady. (..). The Life and Opinions of Major General Sir Charles Metcalfe MacGregor, (Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2013).

Sunday, March 24, 2024

Kishen Kant Bose’s Mission to Bhutan – 1815

 

Gorkha after the conquest of Nepal expanded aggressively and took over many neighboring States such as Palpah, Patan and others. This Gurkha expansion came as a blow to the British’s policy of expanding towards the Himalayan Region. It also blocked the British trade route to Tibet through Nepal. East India Company tried her best to establish resident at Nepal failed. The East India Company perceived that the war was inevitable with Nepal one day or the other. The Company employed David Scot to collect information about Nepal. Scot was further asked to communicate with Sikkim, Tibet and Bhutan that these countries remained neutral during the Anglo–Nepalese war.

 

His Excellency [the Governor-General] further desires that you will be pleased to endeavor to open a channel of communication with the administration of Lassa, in order to afford the means of conveying to the authorities there such an intimation of the origin and objects of our proceedings towards the Nepalese, and the encouragement which it is proposed to afford to the Raja of Sikkim, as shall enable them to appreciate the justice and moderation of our conduct. A similar communication might also be conveyed to the Deb Raja.[1]

 

In the meantime, rumors were spread that Gurkha instigated Bhutanese to join them to attack Sikkim to rise against the Company. In addition, there were reports that the Bhutanese troops encamped at Dalimkote. For instance, in 1814 N Macleod, the Commissioner of Cooch Behar informed the Bengal Government that the Bhutanese were making hostile preparations. He speculated that the Gorkha had sent its agent to Bhutan to instigate the Bhutanese against the Company. He advised the Bengal Government to keep enough arms and ammunitions in Cooch Behar to protect any attack from Bhutan. Lord Hastings also requested the Desi of Bhutan to refuse a passage through Bhutan to the Gorkha and to employ every means of his power to oppose Gorkha. In 1815, Macleod also wrote to the Government of Bengal that the Raja of Cooch Behar was in secret communication with the Bhutanese seeking their aid to shake off his dependence upon the Company. He further said that the Raja of Cooch Behar had sought aid of large military force by offering the Bhutanese the land of Maraghat.[2]

Scot was therefore given the task to find out the truth of the news. David Scot won the heart of Bhutanese leader to receive the British envoy Kishenkant Bose in 1815 at the court of the Desi of Bhutan.  Kishenkant Bose started his journey from Goalpara through Sidli to Chirang and reached Punakha. It was found out that Bhutanese were not hostile to the Company.  Kishenkant Bose reported that although there was not much military alliance between Gorkha and Bhutan, Bhutanese were friendlier to the Gorkha than to the Company.

Bose observed that Bhutan was friendly to Gorkha. This was because Bhutan and Gurkha had priest – patron relations from the time of Zhabdrung Ngawang Namgyal, the founder of Bhutan. It was not a military alliance between the two countries.

 Bose also wrote in his report that the Desi of Bhutan suspected that Raja of Cooch Behar had taken possession of the Maraghat with the assistance of the Company. He made every effort to convince the Bhutanese but the Bhutanese were not fully convinced. He suggested the transfer of the Maraghat to the Bhutanese was essential to prevent Bhutan from joining with Gorkha against Company.[3] Kishenkant Bose was accompanied by Rammonhan Ray.[4] Scot himself gathered information through certain Bhutanese merchants discovered that there were no military preparations being made. But Singh was in the opinion that there was some truth in the rumour that they considered to arrange some sort of alliance with during the war.

At this time, the 30th Desi was Sonam Drugyal (1815-1819). In November 1815, David Scott received a letter from Desi of Bhutan saying that he was happy to receive the envoy and his friend. Desi also took opportunity to clarify the Bhutanese stand on the Anglo-Nepalese war of 1814 and gave assurance once again that Bhutan would not attend the Nepalese request against the British interest.



[1] John Bray

[2] Labh (1974)

[3] Labh (1974)

[4] John Bray, Deb (1976), Labh (1974)

Wednesday, February 14, 2024

The East India Company’s Missions to Bhutan and Tibet


 

The East India Company’s Missions to Bhutan and Tibet[1]

The East India Company had desire to have trade relations with Tibet and also with China through lands. The company extended its influence towards north. Trade was being carried out with Tibet through Nepal. But, at the same time, Gorkha also expanded its influence towards south. There were cases of conflict between the two. This affects the company’s trade with Tibet. The Board of Directors asked the Warren Hastings to explore alternative trade routes on 3 May 1771[2].   The golden opportunities knock the door of company, when the Panchen Lama sent a letter to Warren Hastings asking him to cease the hostilities with Bhutan in 1774. This was the first ever contact between Tibet and the Company. Warren Hastings immediately prepared to send the mission to Tibet through Bhutan.

 George Bogle’s Mission to Tibet in 1774

There were many energetic and able officers of the Company. But Hastings’s choice fell on Mr. George Bogle.  Mr. Bogle was an Assistant Secretary to the Board of Revenue at Bengal. He was only 28 years of age. Hastings also officially appointed Bogle his deputy. He chose Mr. Bogle to lead the Mission. He also appointed an assistant surgeon Dr. Alexander Hamilton to attend Mr. Bogle.

The following is the appointment order and the instructions given to George Bogle by Warren Hastings. 

 

Appointment of Mr. Bogle

Fort William, 13th May, 1774.

Sir, —Having appointed you my deputy to the Teshu Lama, the sovereign of Bhutan, I desire you will proceed to Lhasa, his capital, and deliver to him the letter and presents which I have

given you in charge. The design of your mission is to open a mutual and equal communication of trade between the inhabitants of Bhutan and Bengal, and you will be guided by your own judgment in using such means of negotiation as may be most likely to effect this purpose. You will take with your samples for a trial of such articles of commerce as may be sent from this country according to the accompanying Hst, marking as accurately as possible the charge

of transporting them.

You will inquire what other commodities may be successfully employed in that trade. And you will diligently inform yourself of the manufactures, productions, goods, introduced by the intercourse with other countries, which are to be procured in Bhutan, especially such as are of great value and easy transportation, such as gold, silver, precious stones, musk, rhubarb, munjit, etc.

Whatever observations you may make on these or any other subjects, whether of useful knowledge or curiosity, I desire you will communicate to me from time to time, reporting the success of your negotiations. The period of your stay must be left to your discretion. I

wish you to remain a sufficient time to fulfil the purposes of your deputation, and obtain a complete knowledge of the country and the points referred to your inquiry. If you shall judge that a residence may be usefully established at Lhasa without putting the Company to any expense, but such as may be repaid by the advantages which may be hereafter derived from it, you will take the earhest opportunity to advise me of it ; and if you should find it necessary to come away before you receive my orders upon it, you may leave such persons as you shall think fit to remain as your agents till a proper resident can be appointed, and you will apply to the Lama for his permission and the necessary passports for the person who may be hereafter deputed in this character. You will draw on me for your charges, and your drafts shall be regularly answered. To these I can fix no limitation, but empower you to act according to your discretion, knowing that I need not recommend to you to observe a strict frugality and economy where the good of the service on which you are commissioned shall not require a deviation from these rules.

 

Mr. George Bogle.

I am. Sir,

Your most obedient servant,

Warren Hastings.

 

P.S.—I have appointed Mr. Alexander Hamilton, assistant surgeon, to attend you on this deputation.

The main term of reference for the Bogle to carry out with Panchen Lama was as follows:[3]

§  Bogle was to open a communication of trade between Tibet and Bengal

§  Bogle was to take note of the markets and resources of Tibet

§  Bogle was to inv of Tibetestigate the relations between Tibat and China

§  Bogle was to find out all he could about people, politics, manner, morals

The Bogle’s Mission to Tibet through Bhutan

Mr. Bogle began his journey in the mid May 1774 from Calcutta. He arrived at Cooch Behar on 31 May 1774. From Cooch Behar, he travelled to Buxa Duar and reached in the evening.

On 9th June 1774, he began his journey from Buxa Duar to Thimphu. Bhutanese officials at Buxa Duar arranged them two tangun ponies. After two days of his arrival at Thimphu, he was given an audience by new Desi with traditional ceremony in the Tashihchodzong on 5th July 1774.

Bogle’s next step is to march towards Tibet. At first, he was denied permission to enter into Tibet. There were many reasons given, saying that no foreigners were allowed to Tibet, an outbreak of smallpox was unsafe to travel in Tibet and Chinese were objecting the Bogle’s coming to Tibet. So, Mr. Bogle was asked to return to Calcutta.

“The Tashi Lama to Mr. Bogle: Is glad to hear that he has arrived at Cooch Behar and intends to proceed to him. His country is under the dominion of the King of China who has ordered that no Indian, Mughal, Pathan or European should be admitted into it. Regrets his inability to see him and requests him therefore to go back to Calcutta. Letters etc., if he has any for him, may be made over to someone travelling this way. Will send a representative, when the summer season is over”.[4]

 Later Bogle came to know the reason that Panchen Lama mistook for a sort of military expedition when he heard two foreigners with large porters reached Bhutan in their way towards Tibet. Therefore, Panchen Lama denied the Bogle’s permission to enter into Tibet. However, in time, Panchen Lama was informed that the group was on peaceful mission. Then only Panchen Lama sent a letter to Desi of Bhutan to inform the Bogle and his team to proceed to Tibet.

So, on 18th August 1774, Desi of Bhutan read him a letter from Panchen Lama of Tibet informing that Panchen Lama had written to Lhasa authority about the passport and he obtained it.  Panchen Lama further informed that Bogle should have limited number of attendants to come to Tibet.

He left Thimphu on 13th October 1774 to Phari after receiving welcoming note from Panchen Lama of Tibet. Mr. Bogle, Hamilton and Purander were joined by Mirza Setter a Kasmiri, Pema who was sent by Panchen and Desi’s attendant to reach them till the border between Bhutan and Tibet.

Finally, on 7th December 1774, Mr. Bogle arrived at Tashi Lhunpon Monastery. Bogle’s first meeting with the Panchen Lama went well. Both spoke Hindi. Mr. Bogle spent more than five months at Zhigatse with Panchen Lama.


  The Panchen Lama requested Bogle if the Company could repair the Buddhist temple in Calcutta that had been destroyed by Muslims. As soon as Warren Hastings learned of the Panchen Lama's request, Hastings ordered a Buddhist temple to be built.

 Bogle could not go to Lhasa. He returned and reached Bhutan on 8 May 1775.  Bogle signed a treaty with the Desi of Bhutan in 1775 on his return journey from Zhigatse. This is a complementary of the Anglo-Bhutanese of 1774, which conceded some privileges to Bhutanese traders. But Desi of Bhutan allowed only Hindu and Muslim to travel through Bhutan to Tibet.

Warren Hastings adopted a soft policy towards Bhutan. The terms of the Anglo-Bhutanese treaty were lenient to Bhutanese is shown in the territorial concession made to Bhutan. Warren Hastings knew that if the trans-Himalayan trade is to be successful, then Company should adopt such policy and implement to serve their interests.

Bogle finally came back at Calcutta on 3o May 1775. Bogle was appointed as the Collector of Rangpur.  He organized a fair at Rangpur to encourage the both Tibetan and Bhutanese merchants to come and carry out trade with company.

Warren Hastings was about to send Bogle to Tibet for the second time in 1779, unfortunately unsuccessful as the Panchen Lama passed away in 1780 and Bogle himself died at Calcutta in 1781 at the age of 35.

 

Dr. Hamilton’s Mission to Bhutan – 1776 – 1777 

Dr. Hamilton accompanied Mr. George Bogle to Tibet through Bhutan in 1774. He had traveled through Bhutan and reached Zhigatse of Tibet. Warren Hastings, the Governor General of Bengal sent Dr. Hamilton to Bhutan in 1776. He was all alone. He arrived in the Bhutanese frontier in January 1776. There, he received a letter of invitation from the Desi of Bhutan. He proceeded to Punakha straight and reached Punakha on 6 April 1776. The following month, in May 1776, he came to Thimphu.

The objective of the Mission was to investigate the claims of the Desi of Bhutan about the districts of Ambari-Falakata and Japesh. Dr. Hamilton found the Bhutanese claims right. Dr. Hamilton insisted that Ambari-Falakata and Japesh should be given to Bhutan. He reasoned that the Company would be benefitial in term of trade.[5] Another hidden reason of the Company was that the company was expecting Bhutan would levy favourable transit duty on the Compnay goods passing through Bhutan.[6]

Then, Dr. Hamilton returned to Calcutta. But in the following year, Dr. Hamilton was again sent to Bhutan. This time, the main purpose of the Mission was to congratulate the new Desi. The new Desi was the Jigme Sengye (reign: 1775-1788), an incarnation of the 10th Desi Mipham Wangpo (reign: 1729-1736) who were the reincarnations of Gyalse Tenzin Rabgye, the fourth Desi of Bhutan.

Samuel Turner Mission - 1783

 Lieutenant Samuel Turner was a relative of Warren Hastings. He joined the East India Company in 1780. In February 1782, news reached at Calcutta that the reincarnation of the 3rd Panchen Lama was discovered. 

Warren Hastings sent the mission to Tibet to congratulate the reincarnate new Panchen Lama. Turner was appointed on 9 Jan. 1783 chief of the mission. He followed the route previously taken by Bogle.  Turner reached the summer palace of the Desi of Bhutan early in June 1783. Captain Turner ceded, by order of his Government, the districts of Ambari Fala-kottah and Jalpaish to Bhutan, in accordance with the advice of Dr. Hamilton.  

Samuel Turner stayed till 8 September in Bhutan for about three months, and then went on to Tashi-lhunpo, a monastery of Zhigatse.  He arrived there on 22 September 1783.

On 4th December 1783, he had an audience with the young Panchen Lama. Turner presented all the presents and gifts of the Governor General to the Young Lama. The young lama was 18 months old only.


The route followed by Bogle, Hamilton and Turner while visiting Tibet through Bhutan

Note: The route is not to the scale.



[1] The information is based on the “Narratives of the Mission of the George Bogle to Tibet and the Journey of the Thomas Manning to Lhasa by Clements R. Markham.

[2] Sigh (1988)

[3] Lamb (1986), Singh (1988)

[4] Substance of a letter from Tashi Lama to Bogle, who received it at Tashichodzong and sent it on to Calcutta, where it arrived on 8 August 1774 quoted by Lamb

[5]Ghoshal, (1942)

[6] Singh (1988)

The Roles of Trongsa Penlop Ugyen Wangchuck in the Conflict between the British Raj and Tibet in 1888

  The Roles of Trongsa Penlop Ugyen Wangchuck in the Conflict between the British Raj and Tibet in 1888 We know Trongsa Penlop Ugyen Wangc...