Sunday, January 21, 2024

Bhutan and Assam

 

Bhutan and Assam

Bhutan and Kamarup

Like Cooch Behar, Assam was the part of the ancient kingdom of Kamarup. Kamarup was also known as Pragjyostipur. Pragjyostisa was the capital of the kingdom of Kamarup which was located near the present day Gawahati. Bhutanese source says that a Bhutanese monk served as a Royal preceptor in the court of Pragyostisa in Assam. But Nath, B.  writes that a monk was from Leh. However, whether a monk was a Bhutanese or Ladhaki national, the monk was a Buddhist. Assam had many Buddhist pilgrimage sites. One of the important sites was Hajo. Hajo was the important pilgrimage site in Assam in the past. In addition, Hajo was the centre of the trade transaction in the region. The people from eastern Bhutan and also from Tibet visited Hajo annually, while people from western Bhutan carried out trade with Cooch Behar or Rangpur.

Both Tibetan and Bhutanese considered “Sa Chog Drong” for Hajo, the place where Lord Buddha entered into Nirvana.[1] Actually it was a mistake and both Tibetan and Bhutanese did not aware that Buddha passed away at Kusanagar.

Bhutan and Ahom Kingdom

From 13th century onwards, Assam was ruled by Ahom Kings for about six hundred years.  Bhutanese were given the rights to administer Assam duars by the Ahom Kings. In return, Bhutanese paid tributes to the Ahom Kings in kinds.

The seven Assam Duars extended from the Bhutan frontier to the Gohain Kamala Ali. The five Duars were located in the Kamrup district of Assam while the other two were in the Darrang district. Bhutanese administered the five duars of the Kamarup district fully but a unique system was practiced with the other two duars of Darrang. Bhutanese administered two duars of Darrang from December to June while Ahom King administered from July to November. Therefore, in a year, Bhutanese controlled the two duars of Darrang for about seven months whereas Ahom King five months. But Phukan writes that the two duars of Darrang remain under the control of Ahom Government from 15th June to 15th October.

The Bhutanese tributes to the Ahom King include yak tails, Horses, Blankets, musks, daggers and gold dust etc.

 

Sl.No

Items

Quantity

1

Yak Tails

94

2

Horses

36

3

Musk

24 (pieces)

4

Blankets

44

5

Daggers

24

6

Gold dust

24

 

Source: Lahiri

Assam sources say that later disputes arose between Bhutanese and Ahom Governments because Bhutanese defaulted in paying tributes. However, the disputes were settled peacefully. Later on, another dispute arose but each time a settlement was reached either by signing an agreement or paying compensation by the Bhutanese.

 

The tribute for the five Duars in Kamarup was as followed.

 

Items/Duar

Banska

Gaukealla(Gharkola

Chapa Khamar

Chapaguri

Bijni

Cash

901

395

450

546

260-4-0

Gold (tola)

11

2

2

11

11

Ponies

15

5

5

16

16

Musk (bag)

11

2

2

11

11

Yaktails

11

2

2

11

11

Daggers

11

2

2

11

11

Blankets

11

2

2

11

11

 

Source: Majumdar (1984)

 

“However, towards the end the seventeenth century, the Ahom came into conflict with Bhutan when in 1688, an Ahom officer who had gone to collect taxes for four months had been resisted. An engagement took place with greater loss on the Ahom side. Subsequently the conflict was compromised by payment of money by the Bhutias. There was again trouble when a Choudhury of Assam who was sent to collect taxes from Kariapar Duar area was killed. When the Barphukan dispatched a strong force to punish those guilty, they paid money compensation and the matter was closed. There had been again some trouble in the Kariapar area for nonpayment of taxes towards the close of the century. But the Ahom Government enforced them to pay”.[2]

 

In the early 19th century, there was an exchange of visits between Bhutan and Ahom Government. The article was written by J.N. Phukan who submitted to the Centre for Bhutan Studies for publication.

 

The relations between Bhutan and Assam was disrupted by the East India Company in 1828, when East India Company took the Assam under its control.

 

References

§  Lahiri, Dr. Rebati Mohan. 1954. The Annexation of Assam (1824- 1854), Generral Printers & Publishers Limited, Calcutta.

§  Majumdar, A.B. 1984. Britain and the Himalayan Kingdom of Bhotan, Bharati Bhawan, Patna.

§  


[1] Waddel (1893)

[2] Phukan.

 

Saturday, January 20, 2024

Bhutan and Cooch Behar

 

Bhutan and Cooch Behar

Bhutan had contact and good relations with the countries of the south of Bhutan from the ancient time. During the 13th century CE, Phajo Drugom Zhigpo was given the gifts such as talking parrot and other items etc. by the ruler of Kamarup.

Bhutanese trader, Darchug Gyaltshen from Chapcha introduced the Raja of Cooch Behar to Zhabdrung Ngawang Namgyal.

Zhabdrung Ngawang Namgyal and Cooch Behar.

Darchug Gyaltshen from Chapcha invited Zhabdrung to Chapcha. People of Chapcha received blessing from Zhabdrung and people offered gifts to Zhabdrung.  Darchug Gyaltshen and the Maharja of Cooch Behar were good friends. Darchug Gyaltshen informed Maharaja Cooch Behar that Zhabdrung Rinpoche was at Chapcha. The Maharaja sent Zhabdrung Ngawang Namgyal silver coins, gold coins, an ivory tusk, and cloths along with letter. Bhutanese ruler Zhabdrung Ngawang Namgyal in return sent the Cooch Behar Maharaja sacred knotted threads, blessed pills, a saddle and a set of riding items. Zhabdrung Ngawang Namgyal wrote the following letter:

“You, my friends have prayed well in your past life. Though we live in different places, our minds are united. Having received your letter and precious gifts, I am extremely delighted. I have deeply prayed for your happiness now and for the future”. [1]

Prior to this event, the Cooch Behar Maharaja was Bir Narayan (1621-1626). The Portuguese Jesuits after visiting the Raja Bir Narayan at Cooch Behar came to Bhutan and visited Zhabdrung Rinpoche in 1626. On another occasion, Zhabdrung Ngawang Namgyal sent a letter advising the Maharaja of Cooch Behar to practice Buddha Dharma. Maharaja responded by saying he was practicing the Buddha Dharma and Maharaja sent Zhabdrung Ngawang Namgyal a text of Gyatongpa.

The 4th Desi Gyalse Tenzin Rabgye (reign: 1680-1694) and Cooch Behar

The relations between Cooch Behar and Bhutan continued even after the passing away of Zhabdrung Rinpoche in 1651. The successive Desis of Bhutan maintained good relations with Rajas of Cooch Behar and helped them in maintaining order whenever there were internal disputes and also further assisted them, whenever there was an invasion from Mughal in the west. For instance, in 1661, Cooch Behar was invaded by Mir Jumla of Bengal. Maharaja Pran Narayan fled to Bhutan. The Mughal demanded the surrender of Maharaja Pran Narayan from Bhutanese Desi. But Bhutan did not yield to the demand of the Mughal. Maharaja Pran Narayan returned to Cooch Behar in 1663 and reclaimed the throne with the help of Bhutanese. This incident coincided with the reign of second Desi Tenzin Drukdra (reign: 1656- 1667). The second Desi Tenzin Drukdra also received gifts from Raja of Cooch Behar on the occasion of his Enthronement.

The second Desi Tenzin Drukdra was succeeded by Chogyal Minjur Tenpa (reign: 1667 – 1680) and became the third Desi of Bhutan. There was a conflict between the Maharaja Madan or Mod Narayan (1665- 1680), the 7th Maharaja of Cooch Behar and Nazir Mahi Narayan who was the brother of Maharaja Pran Narayan. In the beginning, he was an advisor to the Maharaja but later a conflict arose between the two. A fierce battle was fought. Nazir Mahi Narayan was defeated in the battle and fled the country. His son came to Bhutan and took shelter. Nazir’s son attacked Cooch Behar with the help of Bhutan. However, Bhutanese forces were pushed back to Bhutan.

In the meantime, Basu Dev Narayan (1680 - 1682) was enthroned as the 8th Maharaja of Cooch Behar. Later on, again the two sons of Nazir Mahi Narayan, Yajna Narayan and Jagat Narayan with Bhutanese forces attacked Cooch Behar.

In Bhutan, Gyalse Tenzin Rabgye (reign: 1680-1694) was enthroned as the fourth Desi. In 1680, during the occasion of the enthronement of the 4th Desi Tenzin Rabgye, a daughter of Maharaja Pran Narayan came to Bhutan with 700 gold coins, 1000 silver coins and cloths of five colors of gifts. Not long after Tenzin Rabgye became the 4th Desi, king of Cooch Behar sent a letter requesting the Desi to send the Zimpon as a representative. Therefore, Zimpon Norbu was sent to Pasakha. There was Mughal invasion in Cooch Behar in 1683. Paro Dronyer Zhidhar and the Dalimkote Dzongpon launched an attack on the Mughal. The Mughal leader Maha Kumar fled to Nepal. Again there was a rebellion against the Maharaja by his minister called Kunkuridzoki Dewa. Although zimpon Norbu was sent for mediation, Bhutan received a letter requesting for an armed force. Desi therefore sent Bhutanese army to save the Maharaja. Desi instructed Zimpon Norbu to solve the dispute diplomatically avoiding killings. In 1691, Raja Rub Narayan visited the court of the Desi Tenzin Rabgye with lavish gifts.

The 13th Desi Sherab Wangchuk (reign: 1744- 1763)

Bhutan maintained relations with Cooch Behar through teachings of Buddhism. The Eight Desi Druk Rabgye (reign: 1707 – 1719) banned the practice of sati in Cooch Behar which did not last long. Later on, the 13th Desi Sherab Wangchuk (reign: 1744- 1763) continued the teachings and resumed the abolition of the sati practice. It was successful and thus saved the lives of many people. Desi also offered generous gift of twenty horses and musk to the people of Cooch Behar and Mugshudha. The son of Dharam Deva of Cooch Behar was a follower of Drukpa School. The king and Ministers of Cooch Behar sent to Desi letters accompanied with many objects of gold and silver.

Bhutan Controlled Cooch Behar Affairs.

There were conflicts among the relatives of the Royal of Cooch Behar for power. When they could not solve the problems, they approached the Bhutanese leaders for assistance. Sometimes the situations became worst and the ruler cannot manage the affairs of the country without the aid of the Bhutanese leaders.  As a result, Cooch Behar became the dependent of Bhutan from 1765 onwards till 1773. This is confirmed by Mujamdar (1984). The following paragraphs show us how Cooch Behar became dependent of Bhutan.

During the reign of Maharaja Upendra Narayan (1714 – 1763), Whyte (2002) writes that Dina Narayan was enthroned as king in 1763 with the help of Mughal Foujdar of Rangpur. Upendra Narayan reacted by asking supports from Bhutan. Bhutan helped defeating Mughal. Devendra Narayan (1763 – 1765) became the 12th Maharaja of Cooch Behar. He was a minor of four years old. There were intrigues and conflicts during his reign in the country. Bhutan kept its representative at the court of the Maharaja of Cooch Behar. Bhutan built forts at capital of Cooch Behar. The situations of Cooch Behar became worst that it was impossible to run the country without Bhutan’s involvement in the affairs of the Cooch Behar. 

Maharaja Dhairjendra Narayan (1765 – 1770) the cousin of the Maharaja Devendra Narayan became the 13th Maharaja. His reign also saw the conflicts and intrigues. The former Maharaja Devendra Narayan was assassinated by Rajguru Ramananda Goswami the loyalist of the Present Maharaja. Bhutanese Desi sent force to arrest Goswami. Goswami was taken to Bhutan and imprisoned him or even executed. Bhutan then sent its agent Pagsam Drungpa (Bhutanese Officer Incharge of Buxa Duar) at the court of the Cooch Behar. Therefore, Bhutan virtually ruled Cooch Behar during this time of the period.

Desi Zhidar’s attacks on Cooch Behar.

In 1768, Zhidar became the 16th Desi of Bhutan. In 1969, during the enthronement ceremony of the king Kamadatta of Vijaypur, a small country which is located between the east of Gorkha and south west of Sikkim, Bhutan was invited for the occasion. In response, Desi Zhidar sent his representatives.  In 1770, Bhutan attacked Vijaypur as Bhutan was instigated to invade Vijyapur by the relatives of the assassinated Kamadatta or the other enemies of the Dewan to punish the Buddhikana. Bhutan’s invasion of Vijaypur was temporary only and later withdrew. But Phuntsho (2013) writes that Vijyapur ruler did not pay annual tax tribute to Bhutan.

 Bhutan invited Cooch Behar to join Bhutan in the invasion of Vijyapur. The Dewan Ram Narayan led the forces of Cooch Behar. The joint forces of Bhutan and Cooch Behar defeated the ruler of Vijaypur. Dewan Ram Narayan returned with large captured properties. He gave Maharaja small portion and kept himself large chunk of the property, which he got as war booty. Therefore, Dewan Ram Narayan was killed by the Maharaja’s agent. Bhutan captured Maharaja Dhairjendra at Buxa Duar in the annual party organized by the Bhutan. He was taken to Punakha the then capital of Bhutan.

Maharaja Rajendra Narayan (1770 – 1772) was crowned as the 14th Maharaja by Bhutan. He was the second elder brother of Maharaja Dhairjendra. But the Maharaja did not have power to run the administration of the country. Of course the country was ruled by the Bhutanese agent who was posted at the court of the Cooch Behar. Rajendra Narayan passed away in 1772 A.D. due to illness. Maharaja Dharendra Narayan (1772 – 1775) became the 15th Maharaja of Cooch Behar. Maharaja Rajendra Narayan did not have his successor to the throne. The Nazir Deo, Queen and other Royal courtiers met and decided to enthrone Dharendra Narayan, the son of former Maharaja Dhairjendra as the next Maharaja.The decision was not approved by the Bhutanese agent at Cooch Behar. He came to Bhutan and reported the situations at Cooch Behar to Desi Zhidar. Furious with the circumstances, Desi Zhidar sent an army of 40, 000 to invade the capital of Cooch Behar. The Nazir Deo also came with his forces to counterattack Bhutanese forces. Bhutanese forces were defeated and they were forced to retreat. Desi Zhidar sent additional 18000 soldiers led by Zimpon to fight back the forces of Nazir Deo. This time, Nazir Deo’s forces were defeated. Bhutanese forces captured capital of Cooch Behar. Then Bhutanese enthroned Birendra Narayan, the son of Dewan as the 16th Maharaja of Cooch Behar. At this juncture, Nazir Deo approached the East India Company for help to oust the Bhutanese forces from Cooch Behar. The East India Company readily came to the rescue of the Cooch Behar. Bhutan was defeated and pushed back to the hills of Bhutan. The East India Company and Cooch Behar signed a treaty in 1773. Since then Cooch Behar became the protectorate of the East India Company.

References

Dzongkha Sources

§  Tshewang, Lopon Padma. 1994. Druk Gi Gyalrab, Druk Salwai Dron Me, National Library, Thimphu.

§  Lhundrup, Je Ngawang. (..), 2005. Gyalse Tenzin Rabgye’s Biography, KMT, Thimphu.

English Sources

§  Baillie, Luiza Maria. Father Estevao Cacella’s Report on Bhutan in 1627, Journal of Bhutan Studies, Thimphu.

§  Rhodes, N.G. Coinage in Cooch Behar

§  Ryley, J. Horton. 1899. Ralph Fitch, England’s Pioneer to India and Burma, His Companions and Contemporaries, with his remarkable narrative told in his own words, London, T. Fisher Unwinpaternoster Square.

§  Subedi, Dr. Raja Ram.  Historical Entity of Vijayapur State, retrieved from (https://www.nepjol.info/index.php/VOH/article/view/83/76)

§  Tshewang, Lopon Padma. 1994. (Translated by Jagar Dorji). History of Bhutan, The Luminous Mirror to the Land of the Dragon, KMT Printers and Publisher, Thimphu.

§  Whyte, Brendan. R. 2002. Waiting for the Esquimo, and historical and documentary study of the Cooch Behar enclaves of India and Bangladesh, retrieved from (https://minervaaccess.unimelb.edu.au/bitstream/handle/11343/34051/66438_00001443_01_whyte.pdf

§  http://coochbehar.nic.in/Htmfiles/royal_history.html, "Kochbiharer Itihas", 2nd edition (1988), by Shri. Hemanta Kumar Rai Barma



[1] Jagar Dorji

Thursday, January 18, 2024

BHUTAN and SIKKIM


 

BHUTAN and SIKKIM

Bhutan and Sikkim were small Buddhist countries in the eastern Himalayas. Both became the Nation States in the 17th century CE. The two countries shared border. Therefore, it is an inevitable that there would be some forms of contacts between the two countries. The marriage of a Bhutanese woman by the second Chogyal Tensung Namgyal proved beyond doubts the relations existed between the two neighboring countries, although there were no details records being mentioned neither in Bhutanese nor in Sikkim’s sources. The interaction primarily consisted of a series of attacks and counterattacks.

According to the Bras lJong rGyalrab[1] the first ever conflict between Bhutan and Sikkim occurred in 1700 CE. The Choygyal Tensung Namgyal married a Bhutanese woman called Namgay Wangmo who gave the birth of Princess Pede Wangmo. Namgay Wangmo was the first Gyalmo of the Chogyal. A Prince was also born to Chogyal by his Tibetan woman, the second Gyalmo. Chogyal had a third Gyalmo from the Lepcha Community of Sikkim. At the age of thirteen, Prince Chador Namgyal was enthroned as the third Chogyal of Sikkim, when his father Chogyal Tensung Namgyal passed away. But Princess Pede Wangmo being a senior to prince Chador Namgyal did not welcome the enthronement of the prince Chador Namgyal. She objected and declared she would be the throne holder of Sikkim. Princess Pede Wangmo therefore turned towards Bhutan for assistance to oust the prince Chador Namgyal.

During the crises, one of the Lepcha ministers called Yugthing Tishey secretly taken the prince ruler Chador Namgyal to Tibet. In the absence of the prince ruler, Yugthing Aroop who was an illegitimate son of the late Chogyal Tensung Namgyal was kept as the in charge of the Rabdentse palace. Bhutanese troops captured the Rabdentse palace and Yugthing Aroop was taken to Bhutan and imprisoned. Bhutan controlled Sikkim for about eight years. Within eight years, Bhutan took the repairing of palace, constructed walls and added a building for the water supply. Bhutan also built Namgyal Thonpoi and Wangdu phodang dzongs and a monastery and called Paro Gon in Sikkim.

However, His eminent Jamyang Khentse Choki Lodro writes different story. He writes that Chogyal Tensung Namgyal married a Tibetan Woman, Pema Butri. He mentions neither Bhutanese woman nor Lepcha Woman married by Chogyal Tensung Namgyal. But I am in the view that the royal marriage to Bhutanese woman were possible because in those days, both Tibetan and Bhutanese migrated to Sikkim and settled there. People traveled for trading and pilgrimage purposes.  The migration of Tibetans and Bhutanese to Sikkim has been confirmed by Karubaki Datta, a reliable source. “On the whole, it appears that Bhutia migration took place in phases, one of the earliest, immigrants being one Khye Bumsa. He had established a cordial relation with the Lepchas and was even blessed by the Lepcha wizard for a son. The descendants of Khye Bumsa are divided into six families. With Khye Bumsa came other Tibetans or khampas who founded the 8 fields or the tribe of eight respectable names. These are the 14 original main families of Tibetan origin in Sikkim.Besides these, there are other families of Tibetan origin which form the raichhung or the ‘little families’. They came to Sikkim at various points in time since the establishment of the monarchy and are divided into 8 groups. Like the 14 original families they also enjoy some religious and social privileges particularly pertaining to entry to monasteries. While their exact place of origin is not mentioned specifically, at least one family viz. the sTod-pa or TumnsTod-pa are so called from their having first settled in Tumu or Upper Mochu Valley. After them came others, like the Chumbi–pa, immigrant from Kham in Tibet and Ha in Bhutan, to the lower reaches of the Mochu near Chumbi”.

While Mullard writes that Nga Dag Rinzin Phuntsho joined Princess Pede Wangmo, Bras lJong Gyalrab mentioned she married to the grandson of the Nga Dag Rinzin Phuntsho Rinchen Gon. Bras lJong rGyalrab also mentioned that the reincarnation of the Lhatsun Namkha Jigme was born in Bhutan. He was known as Mi Kyod Gawa, and he also visited Sikkim.. This needs verification from the Bhutanese source.

Later, when the prince Chador Namgyal returned to Sikkim, Bhutanese withdrew from Rabdentse palace but still occupied the eastern Sikkim right from river Teestsa, Damsang, Daling and Kalingpong. However, Bhutanese sources do not mention about the conflict between the princess and prince over the throne of Sikkim. But our sources do mention different conflicts that took place. For example, the conflict between Bhutan and Mon Achog. Bhutanese source placed this conflict before the above mentioned “The first succession war of Sikkim” coined by Mullard. His holiness, Je Ngawang Lhundrup, the author of the biography of the fourth Desi Gyalse Tenzin Rabgye writes that Mon Achog made alliance with the Tibetan (5th Dalai Lama). He got assurance from the 5th Dalai Lama. Mon Achog attacked Daling Dzong and captured it. Desi Chogyal Minjur Tenpa sent Bhutanese forces headed by Dronyer Doley first.  Later, Desi sent additional forces under the leadership of Thimphu Dzongpon Au Tshering. Bhutanese forces recaptured the Daling Dzong. Mon Achog was killed and his hand and head were taken to Bhutan which is a sign of victory over the enemy. This conflict took place in 1676. But another Bhutanese historian Lama Pema Tshewang presents the event in two phases.  He writes that the conflict between Bhutan and Mon Achog had taken place in 1668 and 1676. But his mentioned about the involvement of the Tibetan Depa Trinley Gyamtsho in the conflict in supporting the Mon Achog raised the doubt. According to Tibetan sources, Depa Trinley Gyamtsho resigned from the post of Depa in 1660.

 However, according to the Sikkimese sources, Bras lJong Gyalrab and the Guatam (2014) mentioned that the conflict was taken place after the first succession of war. The first succession of war had happened in 1700- 1708.  Gyalrab mentions that Achok did not have good terms with the Chogyal and turned towards Bhutan for helps. But in the end, Achok ended his life in the hands of Bhutanese. Gyalrab did not mention the involvement of the Tibetan in the conflict between Bhutan and Sikkim. Still there are other sources that tell us different story. For instance, Risley, H.H. (1894/1987) presents that Gyelpo Achoo and Gyelpa Apha were the ancestors of the first Chogyal of Sikkim. The first Chogyal Phuntsho Namgyal was the son of Guru Tenzin who in turn was the son of Gyelpa Apha or Zhal Nga Aphag. There was a conflict between Gyelpo Achoo and Gyelpa Apha, the two cousin families. Gyelpa Apha asked help from Bhutan. Bhutanese general attacked Gyelpo Achoo and killed Achoo at Ambiokh. Risley (1894/1987) further shows us that the conflict between Bhutan and Sikkim took place even before the establishment of Monarchy in Sikkim. Rongngoo (..) writes in his thesis that Achok was the local chieftain of the Damsang region. He was killed by Bhutanese and took over the Damsang, Daling and Kalingpong. But he did not specify the year or the period in which Achok lived. However, two things are common in all the stories mentioned above. One is that Achok was assassinated by Bhutanese and the second, Achok was the chieftain of Damsang, Daling and Kalingpong region.

 Gyurme Namgyal became the 4th Chogyal of Sikkim. But he left Sikkim and went to Tibet. During his absence, a conflict emerged again between Bhutan and Sikkim. Bhutan raised the boundary issue with Sikkim. Tibetan sent the Depa of Tsang Chanlochen to mediate the disputes. The first attempt failed. Another meeting was held at Phari. A boundary was fixed at Rongchu.  Although it is not mentioned in the Bhutanese sources, it seemed that the conflict took place in 1725-26 during the reign of the 9th Desi of Bhutan.

In 1733, Namgyal Phuntsho became the 5th Chopgyal of Sikkim. Namgyal Phuntsho was born to a nun out of weblog. Therefore, one of the ministers Tamding and his brother did not recognize the young Chogyal. He took the throne for himself. He ruled Sikkim about three years. Another minister, Karwang supported the young Chogyal. The young Chogyal was taken to Bhutan for safety reasons and kept in Bhutan till he attained age. Then Karwang asked assistance from Bhutan. There was a severe war between the two groups. The joint forces of Karwang and Bhutan defeated the Tamding. Tamding went to Tibet to ask for assistance. The Tibetan government sent Rabden Sharpa to Sikkim as an agent.

Again, the conflict emerged in Sikkim. This time, the Mangar chief revolted against the Rabden Sharpa when he refused to accept the chieftainship of the new Mangar chief. As usual the Mangar chief sought help from Bhutan in 1746. Of course, the joint forces failed in their pursuits in 1747. However, Karwang persuaded the Rabden Sharpa to enthrone Namgyal Phuntsho on the throne of Sikkim.[2]  This war occurred during the reign of the 12th Desi Ngawang Gyaltshen (1739-1744).[3]  Bhutanese was given the local rights in Gangtok and allowed to keep a small garrison. Tenzin Namgyal became the 6th Chogyal of Sikkim. In 1788 Gorkha attacked Sikkim. The Gorkha forces captured the Rabdentse palace of Sikkim. The Chogyal Namgyal fled to Chumbi valley of Tibet. Although Bhutan used to attack Sikkim in the past several occasions, this time Bhutan supplied rice, tea and coins to Chogyal Tenzin Namgyal.[4] But Mr. Rai is in the view that Bhutan offered assistance to Tibet.

Another interesting thing with regard to the relationship between Bhutan and Sikkim is the discovery of the certificates issued by the Bhutanese Government to Yugthing Chog Thub by Mullard. Mullard studied the documents and translated into English and also provided transliteration. In 1790, the Paro Ponlop issued certificates to Yugthing Chog Thub, followed by the central government's issuance the following year. These certificates hold historical significance, as they were granted to the same individual. The certificates were issued to Yugthing Chog Thub for thanking him for his services to Bhutan Government. He came forward and helped put down the rebellion. He was given the rights to collect both the summer and winter taxes from the people living in Damsang, Daling and Kalimpong areas. He was also given freedom to travel in the southern plains. But what is not clear to us is “who organized revolt against whom”? Of course, Bhutanese source mentions that the supporters of the late Desi Zhidar revolted against the Central Government time and again. This confirmation was substantiated by Samuel Turner's report in 1783.

However, Bras ljong Gyalrab mentions that Yugthing Chog Thub was the war hero of the Gorkha –Sikkim war of 1771, 1775 and 1788. He felt insecure to live in the western Sikkim. Bhutanese Government allowed him to live in the Bhutanese territory of eastern Sikkim where Bhutanese Government need not had to appoint a native officer. It appears that the Bhutan government issued a certificate to Yugthing Chog Thub during the reign of the 18th Desi Jigme Singye (1775-1788). From the transliteration provided by Mullard, I wrote in our national language:

Document No.: PD/9.5/007

༉         ད་ལམ་  ཕྱག་མཛོད་མཆོག་ཐུབ་ཕ་བུའི་སྐོར་ལ་            སྔ་ཕྱི་རིམ་པར་     སྒོ་གསུམ་            ཐ་དད་ནས་         རེ་ལྟོས་སྐྱབས་འཇུག་སོགས་       གང་ཡང་            ཆོས་རྗེ་འབྲུག་པར་            ཚོལ་ཞིང་            དེ་མ་ཟད་           རིང་སྤུངས་          ནང་ཟིང་སྐབས་ཀྱང་      གཏམ་ཐོས་པའི་མེད་ལ་      ལུས་སྲོག་ཏུ་མ་ལྟོས་པར་འོང་སྟེ་        ཕྱག་ཕྱི་   བསམ་པ་ལྷག་མེད་ཀྱིས་      གུས་པའི་            ཞིག་གསོ་      བཅས་ལ་            གོངས་ས་རིན་པོ་ཆེ་ནས་ཀྱང་           སྤྱན་རྒྱངས་བརྩེ་གཟིགས་ཆེན་པོས་     མཆོག་ཐུབ་པའི་    ཟས་་གོས་ཀྱི་            ཐུན་དེབས་དང་    ལྟོ་ཐུས་བཅས་ལ་   གོངས་ཞབས་ཀྱི་    སྒེར་རྒྱ་སྔོན་རྒྱ་གར་           ལོ་ཁྱི༌སྡོད༌སྐུལ༌༌༌༌༌༌ཀྱི༌རམ༌རིང༌གི༌ཟུར༌རྒྱ༌དེ༌ནས༌  དབྱར༌ཁྲལ༌དང༌དགུན༌ཁྲལ༌ འབྲུ༌དང༌གྱམ༌ཁ༌དངོས༌པོ༌ཅི༌བྱོར༌ཤལ༌ལི༌ཆུམ༌བཅས༌            མཆོག༌ཐུབ༌རང༌གིས༌          འསྡུ༌མཆོག༌པ༌དང༌དགུན་གྱི་དུས་སུ་   རྒྱ་ཕྱོགས་            ཚོང་གྲུལ་བྱེད་ཚར་ཡང་ཆེད་ཕྲ་དུ་ནས་ཀྱང་            ལམ་རྒྱ་མེད་པར་               འགྲོ་ཆོག་པ་དང་   དམ་སང་            རྡར་གླིང་            གསང་སྦས་          རྫོང་གསར་ཕྱོགས་ གང་དུ་ཁོ་པའི་མི་སེར་  ལྷོ་པ་མོན་པ་        རྩོང་ཡུར་པ་སོགས་བབས་པ་ཅི་ཡོད་ཀྱང་        ལྷག་མེད་            མཆོག་ཐུབ་རང་ནས་          ཚད་གཅོད་བྱས་རྗེས་ཡིན་པ་དེས་            གྲོངས་ས་ཡིན་ཚེ་  ཡོད་རིས་ལྷག་མེད་ནར་      བདག་པོར་ཁྲལ་དེས་          སྤྲོད་དགོས་རྒྱུ་དང་            མཆོག་ཐུབ་པ་      ཀ་གླིང་སྤུང་གནས་ཏེ་         འབྲས་ལྗོངས་སུ་    མ་ལོག་པར་         ངོ་ཟླ་ལྔ་ལ་          རྡར་རྫོངས་ནས་    ལོ་གོས་      ཕྱག་མཛོད་་རང་ལ་           གླ་གཉེར་ཐང་དང་ཟླ་བོ་༤་ལ་བོད་ཀྱི་ཁྲལ་      མཆོག་ཐུབ་          རང་ལྟ་གཉིས་སྐལ་སྲོག་བརྒྱགས་            ཉ་བལ་རིལ་༢་དང་           མར་ཁུ་ཤལ་ཁལ་རེ་           ཚྭ་བོད་ཚྭ་དང་རྒྱ་ཚྭ་གང་རུང་          བྲས་(ཆུམ)༡༥་བཅས་བྱིན་དགོས་རྒྱུ་དང་རི་ནག་གྲུང་ཟེར་བ་་་་་དེ་ཡང་            གོངས་སའི་དམར་ཏྲམ་དུ་    ཁོདཔ་ཇི་ལྟར་དང་            གཞན་ཡང་         ཕྱག་མཛོད་མཆོག་ཐུབ་ཀྱི་རིམས་པ་      གང་ཡང་            གཞུང་ས་ཆེན་པོ་ནས་         ལག་ཁྱེར་དུ་གནང་བའི་དན་ཁྲ་དི་དོན་ལ་        རྫོང་བདག་གཉེར་པ་སོགས་ཆེ་ཕྲ་ཀུན་ནས་         སྤང་བླང་ཚུགས་མེད་དུ་ཡོད་པ་གྱིས།   ཞེས་ལྕགས་ཁྱི་ཟླ་༡༡་ཚེས་༣་བཟང་པོར་          འབྲུག་རིན་སྤུངས་ནས་དགེ།

The above certificate was issued in 1790 by the Paro Ponlop.

Document No.: PD/9.5/005

ད་ལམ་   ཡུག་མཆོག་ཐུབ་ཕ་བུ་འདི་དག་        སྔ་ནས་ཀྱང་         ཆོས་རྗེས་ཁྲུག་སར་            སྐྱལ་སྡེང་ཁྲོང་ཞུས་པ་མ་ཚད་           རྗེས་སུ་         བོད་གནས་ཀྱི་ཆགས་རྐྱེན་ལྟ་བུས་      གོར་སྙིང་གིས་      ཡུལ་ཐོན་བྱུང་བ་ནས་        བཅས་་་་་་་་ཁ་ཞེས་མེད་པའི་           བློ་འཕྲལ་ཕུག་དགེ་འབྲུག་བསྟན་པ་གཉིས་སུ་་་་་་་གཟང་བའི་བློ་གཏོད་རིང་འདི་ལོར་ཁོ་རང་ཕ་རིར་སྤུལ་དུ་དགའ་ལྡན་གཞུང་གསར་ཞུ་ཡིག་གི་ལམ་ནས་སླབ་དོན་ཞུས་ཏེ་་་་་་་་་་་དུས་ཀྱང་རིང་སྤུངས་ཟིང་རྐྱེན་སྐབས་ཤར་དུས་པ་ཀྱགས་སྟབས་སུ་ལུས་གྲག་ལ་ག་བལྟོས་པའི་ཁ་ཞེས་མེད་པའི་ཕྱག་གྱིར་རྒྱུར་ཐག་ཞུ་ཁུལ་ཞིག་དང་ཟིང་རྐྱེན་ཞི་འཕྲུལ་མཆོག་ཐུབ་རང་ཞབས་འཇགས་ཀྱིས་ཞུ་སྦྱོར་ལ་དེ་ས་རང་གི་མི་སེར་ཡོད་རིགས་ཀྱི་འཚོ་སྐྱོང་དང་བཅས་      ཀ་གླིང་སྤུངས་      སྡོད་ཆོག་པ།         དམ་སང་རྡར་གླིང་གི་ཆ་ཁུལ་ཁོ་རང་མི་སེར་ལྟི་་་་་་་ཡོད་་་་་ཡུལ་ཐོན་གྱི་རིགས་ཀྱང་སླར་བདག་འཛིན་བྱེད་ཆོག་པ།       ཞིག་ཟས་ཞུ་ནན་ཆེ་བས་ལྟ་བཞིག་གང་བཤད་ལྡ་་་་་་་་་་ཤིས་ལྟོ་བརྒྱགས་ཀྱི་  འཚོ་ཐབས་ལ་ཞབས་པད་རང་གི་            སྒེར་རྒྱ་སྔོན་རྒྱ་གར་ལོ་ཁྱི༌སྡོད་ཤུལ་གྱི་རམ་ལྟེང་གི་ཟུར་རྒྱ་དེར་ད་ལྟ་ག་རྒྱམ་ཞབས་པད་ནས་བསྐོས་གནང་ཞིག་བཞག་པ་དི་རང་དང་མཆོག་ཐུབ་ས་ཀ་གླིང་སྤུངས་         རྡམ་གནས་བར་དུ་རྒྱ་གཞི་དེ་ནས་     དབྱར་ཁྲལ་དང་དགུན་ཁྲལ་འབྲུ་ཁྲལ་ གྱམ་དངོས་པོ་ཅི་བྱོན་དང་ཤལ་ལིའི་ཆུམ་སྔར་ལུགས་བཞིན་    མཆོག་ཐུབ་པས་རྒྱུགས་       ཆོག་པར་            བཀྲིན་བསྐྱངས་ཡོད།           སྒྲའི་གཟུང་གྱུར་ལ་ཚོང་ཁེ་སྤོ་ཡང་བ་རྒྱལ་བ་་་་་་་་་་བདེད་སོང་གཉིས།  རྒྱ་ཕྱོགས་སུ་ཚོང་གྲུལ་བྱེད་པར་དབྱར་སྒང་ལ་ལུང་པ་སྤྱི་ཐོག་ནས་ཚོང་གྲུལ་བྱེད་མི་ཆོག་པ་དེ་རང་ལ་ཆ་གནས་དགོས་པ་དང་དགུན་ཚོང་རིགས་རྒྱ་ཕྱོགས་སུ་ཚོང་གྲུལ་ལམ་གང་དེར་བྱེད་ཆོག་པར་ཆེ་ཕྲ་སུ་ཀྱང་ལམ་འགག་རྒྱ་སྡོམ་མེད་པར་གཏང་ཆོག།གོར་ཁའི་ཁྱུར་ཟིང་སྐབས་འབྲས་ལྗོངས་འདི་ས་ཆའི་ཀོངས་ནས་ཡུལ་ཐོན་གྱི་རིང་ཐོར་རྫོང་གསར་དང་དམ་སང་གསང་སྦས་རྡར་གླིང་ཚོང་མུར་གྱི་མི་སེར་བཅས་པ་བབས་སྡིང་་་་་་་་་ཡོད་ཀྱང་ཆེ་ཕྲ་གང་ཡང་ལྷག་མེད།མཆོག་ཐུབ་རང་ནས་རྩད་གཙོ་བྱས་རྗེས་དེངས་རང་མི་སེར་ཡིན་ངེས་གདོན་མཐོངས་ངེས་ཤེས་འགྲོངས་ཆིས་ལྷག་མེད་ནོར་བདག་པོའི་ལག་སར་འཕྲོད་པ་བྱས་སྤྱོན་དགོས་རྒྱུར།

རྡར་རྫོངས་ས་དང་འདི་གཉེར་སོགས་ལས་ཚན་ཆི་ཁྲ་གང་ནས་ཀྱང་བཀའ་ལ་གནས་ཏེ་སྙད་གཙོར་མེད་པའི་ཐོགས་འགྲོགས་རམ་ཅི་ཕན་ལ་འབད་དགོས་རྒྱུ་དང་ཡང་མཆོག་ཐུབ་པ་ཀ་གླིང་སྤུངས་གནས་ཏེ་འབྲས་ལྗོངས་སུ་ཕྱིར་ལོག་མ་བྱུང་བར་ངོ་ཟླ་༡༠་་་་་་སྒར་རྫོང་ནས་ལོ་གོ་མཆོག་ཐུབ་རང་ལ་གླ་གཉེར་ཐང་དང་ཟླ་བོ་༥་ལ་བོད་ཁྲལ་་མཆོག་ཐུབ་ལ་ཁྲོ་གཉིས་སྐལ་དང་སྲོག་བརྒྱགས་ཉ་བལ་རིལ་གཉིས་་དང་མར་ཁུ་ཤལ་ཁལ་རེ་རྒྱ་ཚྭ་དང་བོད་ཚྭ་གང་རུང་བྲས་(ཆུམ)༡༥་བཅས་བྱིན་དགོས་རྒྱུ།གཞན་ཡང་་རི་ནག་སྤུངས་ཟེར་བ་དེ་ཡང་ད་ཐུགས་ལ་དགེ་འབྲུག་་་་གཉིས་ནས་སྤུང་བྱ་ས་རེ་དེ་ལྟར་ཡིན་བྱུང་།       དགའ་ལྡན་གཞུང་ནས་རི་ནག་དེ་མཆོག་ཐུབ་པར་གནང་འདུག་དང་བརྒྱུན་  མཆོག་ཐུབ་པ་སླར་         འབྲས་ལྗོངས་སུ་མ་ལོག་བར་རྡར་རྫོང་ནས་སྤུང་གསར་བསྐོར་བྱས་མི་ཆོག་པར་རེ་ཞིག་མཛོད་ཡོད།          མཆོག་ཐུབ་ཀྱང་སླར་རང་གནས་ཚངས་སུ་ཚུད་པ་བྱུང་བ་ནས་བརྩམ་རེ་རི་ནག་སྤུང་ས་དེའི་བསྐོ་བཞག་           ཆོས་རྗེ་འབྲུག་པ་རང་གིས་སྔ་གྲོལ་ལྟར་བྱས་པ་ལས་གཞན་གྱིས་བྱེད་མི་ཆོག་པའི་བཀའ་ཁྲ་ལྕགས་ཕག་ཟླ་ཚེས་   ལ་         འབྲུག་བཀྲིས་ཆོས་ཀྱི་ཕོ་ཕྲངས་ནས་བྲིས་པ།      དགེ།

This second certificate was issued in 1791 by the central Government of Bhutan.

Meanwhile, British India made friend with Sikkim to prevent Sikkim from coming to help Gorkha against British India in the Anglo –Gorkha war of 1814-16.  British India rewarded Sikkim by giving back its territories captured by Gorkha in the past, for remaining neutral in the Anglo-Gorkha war. Sikkim ruler granted Darjeeling to British India in 1835.This event took place during the reign of Chogyal Tsurphu Namgyal. Chogyal drew a criticism from both Tibet and Bhutan and he was accused of selling Darjeeling to British India.[5] Bhutan even attempted to kill the Chogyal when he was on the way to Tibet for pilgrimage.[6] Therefore,  Chogyal complained to British India and said: “The neighboring States are perpetually bothering me. It will not do if Darjeeling falls into another State's hands”.[7] Sikkim became the protectorate of British India in 1861. By this time, British India had already taken the Assam duars from Bhutan and had tensions over the Bengal duars. Bhutan disapproved the takeover of Sikkim’s administration by British India, so Bhutan gave shelter to the supporters and relatives  of the exiled Dewan Namgyal of Sikkim.[8] British India stopped the payment of the compensation for the annexation of Fallakota to Bhutan. Bhutan blamed Sikkim for this, British India action and went to Sikkim territory Gopalganj and brought an elephant belonged to Sikkim. This event took place during the reign of Desi Nadzi Passang (1861 – 1863).[9]

After the duar war of 1865, British India wanted to improve the communication with Bhutan by establishing an office of Bhutanese agent at Buxa. British India asked Bhutanese Government to appoint a native Bhutanese officer to be posted as an agent at Buxa. Bhutanese appointed a Sikkimese man called Phento. The Bhutanese leader was the Gongsa Desi Jigme Namgyal. Later on, during the reign of Druk Gyalpo Ugyen Wangchuck, Phento was appointed to teach Bhutanese students at the court school of Bumthang.

A Sikkimese scholar Dawa Samdrup worked at Buxa duar in the office of the British India from 1887 to 1893. While he was at Buxa, he met a Bhutanese lama called Tshampa Norbu. He took Tshampa Norbu as his root lama. Later, he translated the Bhutan History (Lho’ Chos Byung) into English.[10]

It seems, there were no personal contacts between the two leaders after British India took over the administration of Sikkim. But on rare occasions, British India provided opportunities to meet the two leaders. For example, in 1906 and 1911, Druk Gyalpo Ugyen Wangchuck and Chogyal Thutob Namgyal were invited at Calcutta and Delhi. Later in 1935, British India welcomed Druk Gyalop Jigme Wangchuck and Chogyal Tashi Namgyal at Calcutta.

 







Bhutan and Sikkim entered into matrimonial relations, when Gongzin Sonam Tobgye Dorji married Ashi Chos dBying Wangmo, the daughter of the 9th Chogyal Thutob Namgyal.

While, Gongzim Ugyen Dorji served the first Druk Gyalpo, his son Gonzin Sonam Tobgye served the second Druk Gyalpo Jigme Wangchuck. The sibling of Gongzim Sonam Tobgye and Ashi Chos dBying Wangmo includes the present Royal Grant Queen Mother Ashi Kesang Choden Wangchuck, Ashi Tashi, late Prime Minister of Bhutan Jigmi Palden Dorji, late Dasho Ugyen Dorji and late Dasho Lhundrup Dorji (Lumpy). Both Gongzim Ugyen Dorji and Sonam Tobgye Dorji (father and son) served as Bhutanese agents at Buxa duar. Both father and son acted as a bridge between Bhutan and British India.

Many British India political officers for Sikkim visited Bhutan. The first political officer was John Claude White. When his retirement from the service was nearing, Both Sikkim and Bhutan requested the Bengal Government to extend the White’s service by few more years. Mr. White was succeeded by Mr. Charles Bell. The young Prince Tashi Namgyal was enthroned as the next Chogyal of Sikkim. He was not given the full administrative power as he was young. Later, when he attains the age, Mr. Bell proposed to council that the prince be given the full power. Mr. Bell reasoned that through this action, British India would appeal both Tibet and Bhutan and there would be cordial relations in the region.[11]  It appears that both Tibet and Bhutan were dissatisfied with British India's authority over Sikkim.   Druk Gyalpo (1907 – 1926) also carried out the boundary talk with Sikkim and the boundary between Bhutan and Sikkim was fixed at Gipmochi.[12] Later during the reign of Druk Gyalpo Jigme Wangchuck (1927- 1952)also, British India political officers continued to visit Bhutan. In 1943, the prince Thondup Namgyal also came to Bhutan with Mr. Gould, the then political officer for Sikkim. The relations between Sikkim and Bhutan might have enhanced further.

In 1947, on the behalf of the Druk Gyalpo Jigme Wangchuck, Gongzim Sonam Tobgye attended the conference of the Asian relations at New Delhi. At the conference, a national flag of member countries was required to be hoisted. Therefore, Ashi Chos dBying Wangmo Dorji designed a Bhutanese national flag.[13]

 









Courtesy: Tshering Tashi

British India left India in 1947 without making clear about the future status of the Sikkim and Bhutan. There were concerns and worries both in Sikkim and Bhutan. However, Prime Minister of free India made it clear that Sikkim and Bhutan were special case and would not be part of the Indian Union. Meanwhile, Bhutan signed a treaty with independent India in 1949 whereby Bhutan agreed to be guided by India in her external affairs. The following year Sikkim followed suit Bhutan. But Sikkim agreed that India controlled her dense, communication and external affairs of Sikkim. Thus Sikkim became the protectorate of India. Prince Palden Thondup Namgyal actively involved and spearheaded the developmental projects in Sikkim. In Bhutan, his cousin Jigme Palden Dorji also sailing in the same boat. Both of them also underwent training on Indian administrative service course at Dehra Dun.

As there was pressure from both India in the south and China in the north, Sikkim and Bhutan along with Nepal considered the formation of the federation of the Himalayan Kingdom. For this effect, Prince Paldden Thondup and Jigmi Palden made a visit to Kathmandu informally in 1971 but later dropped it.[14]  The concept of federation among Himalayan countries appeared when Basil Gould , the political officer of Sikkim advised the prince Thondup Namgyal to think of the possible alliance among the Buddhist countries consisting of Tibet Bhutan and Sikkim. Later the king of Nepal Mahendra also show interest and willingness to form the one. But it did not materialize. When Jigmi Palden Dorji, the Prime Minister of Bhutan, was interviewed by N. George Patterson, he stated, "I have previously made it clear that I will not entertain the idea of endorsing the proposal for federation, as it would inevitably result in an overwhelming influence from Nepal."[15]

Both Bhutan and Sikkim worked hard to become the member of the UNO. When Sikkim could not become the member of the UNO and when Bhutan was successful in getting the membership, the relations between the two countries declined.[16]








Courtesy: Inside Bhutan, Facebook

Chogyal Palden Thondup Namgyal attended and graced the coronation ceremony of His Majesty the Fourth Druk Gyalpo in 1974. In 1975, unfortunately, Sikkim became the part of Indian Union.

Later, when Chogyal Palden Thondup Namgyal passed away, Bhutan thought of taking the responsibility of carrying out the funeral ceremony but finally done by the Indian Government. However, Her Royal Grand Queen Mother Azhi Kezang Choden Wangchuck attended the funeral ritual of the Chogyal Palden Thondup Namgyal.



[1] Bras ljong Gyalrab was written by the 9th Chogyal Thutob Namgyal and Gyalmo Yeshe sGrolma but I referred the English (translated) version.

[2] Guatam (1914)

[3] Phuntsho (2013)

[4] Tshewang (1994), Pradhan (.) and Phuntsho (2013)

[5] Singh (1988)

[6] Singh (1988)

[7] Singh (1988)

[8] Singh (1988)

[9] Tshewang (1994)

[11] Singh (1988)

[12] Singh (1988)

[13] Tshering

[14] Rustomji (1971, 2008)

[15] Sinha (..)

[16] Duff (2015)

The Roles of Trongsa Penlop Ugyen Wangchuck in the Conflict between the British Raj and Tibet in 1888

  The Roles of Trongsa Penlop Ugyen Wangchuck in the Conflict between the British Raj and Tibet in 1888 We know Trongsa Penlop Ugyen Wangc...